Capernaum and Hades
In our previous study, we had looked at an example of how hades was used in a figurative way, in Mathew 11:23, where Capernaum, who was “exalted to heaven” would be “brought down to hades”.
Now we’re going to see how hades is again used in a figurative sense in the story of the rich man and Lazarus, from Luke 16:19-31. We’ll just examine a few verses from that story.
Luke 16:19-20, “There was a certain (by the way; the word “certain” in the original text, is an indefinite pronoun, which means.. some man, any man. It does NOT mean a specific man) So then.. “There was an indefinite rich man, and he was clothed in purple and fine linen, and lived in splendor every day. And there was a certain (again, indefinite) beggar, named Lazarus (the name Lazarus means.. “one who God helps”) who was laid at his gate and was full of sores”. From these first two verses of the story we have without a doubt, a depiction of one person who is quite exalted in his living condition, and one who is quite humbled, in his living condition.
V-22 tells us.. “Now it came about that the beggar died and was carried away by the angels to Abraham’s bosom..” There’s the humble being exalted. “..And the rich man also died and was buried..” There’s no being carried away to Abraham’s bosom here, and no being exalted. V-23 says, “And in hades, he lifted up his eyes being in torment, and saw Abraham far away, and Lazarus in his bosom.” There’s no doubt here, this man had been humbled! He used to be “rich” and was “dressed in purple and fine linen, and he lived in splendor every day”. But now, he was in torment in “hades”, the humble realm of the unseen!
Listen to the contrast given in this next verse..
V-25 says this about these two men; Speaking to the rich man.. “..Child, remember that during your life, you received your good things, and likewise Lazarus bad things. But now he is being comforted here, and you are in agony.”
Now, has there been a “role reversal” here or what? Has the exalted one been humbled? And has the humbled one been exalted? There’s no denying, that no matter what else you believe this story to be teaching, it IS teaching that “He who was exalted has been humbled, and he who was humbled, has now been exalted.”
It will be up to you, to make up your own mind about the rest of the meaning of the story about the rich man and Lazarus. Ask yourself though.. Does your interpretation contradict other scriptures, with a scene of punishment and reward in hades, or is there another explanation for it’s meaning, is hades simply used figuratively here?
Hades will be cast into the lake of fire
The final book of the bible, the book of Revelation, tells us that at the end of time, hades will give up the souls (the living, unclothed spirits) that are in this unseen realm, and how the hadean realm itself, will be cast into the lake of fire.
The book of Revelation is depicting the scene of the judgment day, in Rev 20:11-15..
“And I saw a great white throne, and Him who sat upon it, from whose presence earth and heaven fled away, and no place was found for them.” V-11. (the present heavens and earth will be done away with, because they will have served their purpose.. 2 Peter 3:7). “And I saw the dead, the great and the small, standing before the throne, and the books were opened; And another book was opened, which is the book of life. And the dead were judged from the things which were written in the books, according to their deeds. V-12-13. (Does that sound familiar? Isn’t that exactly what we read about earlier, how we will be judged and recompensed at the judgment day?) “And death and hades were thrown into the lake of fire. This is the second death, the lake of fire.” V-14. (The first death is when one’s spirit is separated from their physical body. The second death will be when one’s spirit is separated from God eternally, if their name is not in the book of life) And if anyone’s name was NOT found written in the book of life, he was thrown into the lake of fire.” Separation from God! V-15.
When all the dead are resurrected at the judgment day, in other words when hades gives up all the dead that are in that realm, then there will be no further need for hades. And since all souls will have been resurrected, DEATH will have been overcome, and so there will be no need for death either. So then, death and hades will both be thrown into the lake of fire. Just like.. “earth and heaven fled away, and no place was found for them.” Everything that relates in any way with the physical, will be done away with. The physical heavens and earth, physical death itself, and even the spiritual realm where spirits lived, who were separated from their physical bodies.
But until that time comes; Hades is the unseen realm where spirits DO live, after being separated from their bodies at death. It’s a very humble state, where the spirit is unclothed. But it doesn’t really matter that we’ll be unclothed, because the condition of our spirits while in hades is likened to sleep. Remember what we had read from 1 Cor 15:51.. “We shall not all sleep, but we shall all be changed.” We (our spirits) shall not all be separated from our physical bodies before Christ comes again. Some people will still be alive (physical body, and spirit, together) at his coming.
1 Thessalonians 4:14 assures us this.. “For is we believe that Jesus died and rose again, even so God will bring with Him, those who have fallen asleep in Jesus.” V-15 says, “..We who are alive and remain until the coming of the Lord, shall not precede (some versions say “prevent”) those who have fallen asleep.”
Who are “those who have fallen asleep”? Are they not the “living beings” that have departed from their physical bodies? It’s the spirit that is separated from the body at death. But the spirit remains “alive”. The spirit is a “living being”, the spirit is a “soul”. That’s what the word “soul” means.. “a living being”.
So, once again, who are “those who have fallen asleep”? Well obviously, they are the living spirits that have been separated from their bodies at death.
Some people believe that it’s the body that sleeps, not the spirit. But the scriptures say otherwise.
First of all, the body is decaying, not sleeping. Remember how God would not allow His Holy One to see decay? Acts 2:27. But OUR bodies WILL decay, and return to the earth. Gen 2:7 says.. “Then God formed man (the body) from the dust of the ground..” (the earth) Eccles 12:7 says.. “Then the dust (the body) shall return to the earth as it was, and the spirit shall return unto God who gave it.”
Secondly, remember how it’s not the physical body that will be resurrected, but rather a spiritual body? 1 Cor 15:44. “It is sown a natural body, it is raised a spiritual body.”
Third, We just read in 1 Thess 4:14, that God, (Jesus Christ) “will bring with Him, those who have fallen asleep in Jesus”. Jesus is coming to gather the saved, who are the members of His kingdom, and deliver that kingdom to the Father in heaven. 1 Cor 15:24 says, “Then comes the end, when He delivers up the kingdom to the God and Father..” So just think for a second.. Is Jesus going to gather up a bunch of decaying bodies and try to deliver them up to the Father? Of course not. Remember 1 Cor 15:50.. “Flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God!” So then, what exactly IS Jesus going to “gather up”, which is “asleep” in Jesus? Simple common sense will tell you, it’s the spirits of those who have died, that are “asleep”. That’s what Jesus is going to deliver to the Father. Not the bodies, but the spirits!
Those who have fallen asleep, are said to be “in Jesus”. “In Jesus”, or “in Christ”, is a phrase that means to be in a covenant relation with Jesus, and therefore to be in a saved condition. Our bodies are never in a covenant relation with Jesus. Our bodies will not be “saved” for anything. It’s impossible for our bodies to be a part of the spiritual kingdom, that is “not of this realm”, John 18:36. Our bodies are not in a saved condition. It’s our spirits, that are “in Jesus”. Our spirits are “in Christ”.
Our bodies are NOT who we are! Our SPIRITS are who we are. The body is called our “tent”, and our “house” and also our “clothing”, in 2 Cor 5:1-4. If WE are “in Jesus”, it’s our SPIRITS that are being referred to. If WE are brought with Jesus, unto God, it’s our SPIRITS that are being referred to. When the dead “in Christ” shall rise, it’s not our physical bodies that will be rising, it’s our SPIRITS, in a spiritual body that will rise.. 1 Cor 15:42. Remember, death is the separation of body and spirit. The term, “the dead in Christ”, obviously refers to the separated spirits, who are “in Christ”.
When the scriptures say, in 1 Cor 15:18, that if Christ has not been raised, “Then those who have fallen asleep in Christ have perished”.. it’s speaking of our spirits perishing. Our bodies will have already perished. Their job is over, they’ve perished. But it’s the spirit that lives on. Christ’s resurrection is the guarantee of OUR resurrection. And our resurrection will be a spiritual resurrection, not a resurrection of a physical body. Our bodies are not sleeping, they’re decaying, they’re rotting. Our spirits will be “sleeping” after being separated from our bodies.
When our spirits are separated from our physical bodies, they will return to God who gave them. God will safely “keep” them in the spiritual unseen realm called hades. It will be a humble existence, where we will be “unclothed”, and in a condition likened to “sleep”.
THEN, at the resurrection day, “Thou will call, and I will answer!” Job 14:15. It won’t be our body answering, it will be our spirit that answers the call from God.
“For we must all appear before the judgment seat of Christ..” 2 Cor 5;10. What’s going to appear before the judgment seat of Christ.. Our bodies, or our spirits? Well the answer is obvious, our spirits will appear before Christ. Is Christ going to judge our bodies or our spirits? Is He going to recompense our bodies or our spirits? Is it our bodies or our spirits that will be either saved or lost? The obvious answer to all those questions is that it will be our SPIRITS not our bodies. Our spirits will appear, our spirits will be judged, our spirits will be recompensed and our spirits will be either saved or lost eternally.
It is those spirits who have “fallen asleep in Jesus” who will be raised. It is those spirits who have “fallen asleep in Jesus” that He will bring with Him. It is the SPIRITS of those who have died, that will not precede those who remain alive at His coming. And it will be the spirits, of those who have died, who will meet the spirits of those who remain alive, and we will ALL be clothed in our spiritual bodies at that time.
“Therefore if we should live, or if we should die, we are the Lord’s.” Romans 14:8
May God bless you in the study of His word. And may God bless you eternally in your spirit.
Please leave your comments or questions below. I’d be very happy to hear from you. Any comments, questions, or criticisms are welcome.
Thank you for the study on Hades
It may be that we should not dwell on the after life and concentrate on the here and now. However it seems the brethern are almost entirely in agreement that Lazarus and the Rich man is not a parable. I accepted that, knowing it’s not a matter of our Salvation.
Then I listened as two brethern were in a slightly contentious debate on the subject. One (Teaching) totally convinced as fact about the fate of our spirits in paradise or punishment while waiting judgement. The other saying it makes no sense according to scripture.
So I studied it more in depth and see the scripture contradictions and could not get it to line up. Seems a whole doctrine has been put in place based on this parable or as most say, real event. So your article was refreshing after reading so many of our brethern standing firmly on it not being a parable.
Strange as it may seem the denominational websites are very good at laying out all the contradictions of scripture if this is a literal event meant to show our places after death.
Now to my question. What do you make of the Thief being in paradise on that very day with Jesus? or maybe Enoch & Elijah. John 3:13 comes to mind
Thank you
Hi, thanks for commenting. I see your comments were from last January. I’m sorry that I have first seen them today, March 5 th. I hope you will get this reply tp your question though. In my opinion, after much study of the topic of the thief being in paradise with Jesus, and after much study of Luke 23:43, the “popular” understanding of the verse is inaccurate. It comes down to a matter of punctuation actually. When this was written(in the old Greek language) they did not use punctuation, but translators have added punctuation as they believe would be correct. In this instance, I believe their punctuation is not correct. Let me explain; The typical way the sentence is punctuated is as follows.. “And Jesus said to him, “Truly I tell you, today you will be with Me in Paradise.” Well, this is obviously wrong, because even Jesus Himself did not go to “paradise” that very day! “Paradise” in the new testament scriptures, refers to heaven. It does not refer to the “hadean” world of departed spirits. (Spirits who have departed from their physical bodies at death) The word translated as “paradise” is used only three times in the new testament, and it always refers to the same “place” or condition. It refers to heaven!! Here is what I believe to be the proper way to punctuate that verse (which aligns perfectly with scripture) “”And Jesus said to him, “Truly I tell you today; You will be with Me in Paradise.” Do you see the difference? Jesus is telling the thief on that very day, that he would indeed by with Jesus in paradise (heaven). Jesus didn’t tell the thief that they’d be there “today”, but rather, Jesus said that “today I’m telling you, that we will indeed be in paradise together.” And that promise will indeed be fulfilled, when the saved will be brought to heaven on the day that Christ returns to gather the saved. Thank you so much.